4 Comments

  1. Don Cheke
    9 July 2025 @ 6:14 pm

    I really appreciated your insights and views on individually motivated art and culturally motivated art. Or context-wise as you frame it. It has me thinking that I should try to integrate some cultural aspects into some of my art. Again, I am reminded of that artist called Faik Al-aboudi on the forum we follow, who taps into his middle eastern roots. First, I will have to give some thought to what my culture is. Am I a Canadian first and foremost? Is that my culture? Are my roots/culture Hungarian or Polish Ukrainian, based on my parents’ heritage, even though they were both born in Canada. Something to ponder, that is for sure!

    While reading this blog post I had many thoughts about a piece that I am going to create in an aboriginal style, that draws from your writing and an episode of an old TV series I have been watching. Coming across this blog post at this time was quite serendipitous. I have had to take short breaks while reading to make some notes and sketch a couple images to help me remember where I want to go with it. Although I know what elements I want to include, I know that while creating the piece something deeper will appear.

    You sure have some great posts! Your writing is top notch, and I am always glad that I have taken time to read your work.

    Reply

    • Suhail
      10 July 2025 @ 8:33 am

      Thank you, Don, for your thoughtful comment.

      Those questions about whether your culture is Canadian, Hungarian, Polish or Ukrainian are really important and personal. I think exploring them through your art could lead to some truly meaningful work.

      I often find that when you begin with particular ideas or elements, unexpected things happen as the work grows. Sometimes something deeper appears almost naturally.

      When I was writing about different cultural arts, I noticed how they share common themes despite being so different, like storytelling, spiritual meaning, symbols, connections to nature and building identity.

      I can see some of these elements in my own abstract work, especially pieces inspired by nature, storytelling and daily life, though I’m still figuring out where spirituality fits into my own practice.

      Thank you for your kind words about my blogs. I should mention that many of my blogs, including the cultural art ones, originally had lots of public domain images to help explain things better and add value for readers. I made sure to include proper references and credits for every image.

      Even though I know copyright law quite a bit, other legal advisors disagreed with my approach, pointing to different court cases. We discussed this for months, but given my understanding of the legal system, I chose to remove all the images. I feel this has made my blogs less valuable for readers.

      Thanks again for taking the time to share your thoughts.

      Reply

      • Don Cheke
        10 July 2025 @ 3:06 pm

        Thanks Suhail.

        I was very interested to read about your decision to not include public domain art, or anything else, but your own. I had wondered why you never included the examples you mentioned. For the ones you do mention, I typically do a Google search for them so I can see what it is. Usually, I am not familiar with them, so it helps to look.

        We certainly don’t need to rehash this copyright business, since I really don’t know anything in that regard. That said, I am always a bit wary about including another’s art in my blog posts but fall on the belief that doing so in an editorial fashion, with full credit given, is not much different than when one quotes a book in an essay. With the added detail, that I make no money from my blog, I feel that cinches it. The borrowed art or words give the originator some exposure and have not been denied any financial compensation, as there is no money involved.

        Over the years I have seen my art show up in the world. For the most part it was credited appropriately and I did not mind. Just once, one of my lighthouse pencil drawings showed up on someone else’s wedding invitation (uncredited) and I contacted them and had them pay a usage fee, which they did.

        I have shown one or two of your pieces in a couple of my blog posts, with full credit. They were used as a positive example in each case. I hope that you are okay with that.

        Reply

        • Suhail
          10 July 2025 @ 10:58 pm

          Copyright law is like everything else in the legal world, it looks at evidence, solid evidence. Even with that, it doesn’t always prevent a court case from happening. The law is written in grey areas because circumstances can change from one situation to another and from case to case. This is where solicitors come in, they can argue a case over a single word.

          When I was designing my website a few years ago, I spoke to several web designers specifically about copyright issues. They all said roughly the same thing: as long as I include clear, full credit, I should be fine, based on “fair use” or “fair dealing”, particularly if the use is transformative, non-commercial and properly attributed.

          However, the boundaries of fair use aren’t always clear and can vary from country to country. After speaking with copyright advisors, they were of the opinion that giving credit is always good practice, but it doesn’t always guarantee legal protection.

          “Without clear written permission, there’s always a risk of potential infringement.” That was their conclusion. And it didn’t surprise me, because that’s how the law works, there’s often uncertainty even when you think you’re doing everything right.

          The advisors explained that even public domain works can sometimes have complications. For instance, whilst the original artwork might be public domain, a particular photograph or reproduction of it might still be under copyright. It’s these sorts of nuances that make copyright law so tricky to navigate.

          In the end, I decided the safest approach was to remove all images rather than risk any legal issues, even though I know it makes the blogs less helpful for readers.

          As for my own work or blogs, I have no problem with genuine people who may use it as long as they include proper credit and it’s not for their commercial benefit. On the contrary, if anyone finds any value in it, it’s a privilege when others make reference to my blogs or art.

          Thanks Don for raising this interesting issue.

          Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copyright © Suhail Mitoubsi 2025. All rights reserved.